Tuesday, 12 February 2013

Sensa Umbria Tiagra Review

When I was first thinking about buying a new bike, I typed the words "Sensa Umbria Tiagra Review" into google dozens of times over the course of about six months, in the hope of finding an opinion on the bike based on first hand experience. All I ever found were people on web forums asking the same questions that I wanted answered, with no actual reviews to be found anywhere.

I finally went to Merlin Cycles in Chorley to try one, and instantly decided to buy it. Not everyone gets to spend their Christmas half an hour from Chorley though, so I thought I'd write the review that I'd been looking for. 

Now I'll concede straight away that I own the bike. There's no way I can pretend to be objective. On the other hand, I am a hardware reviewer. For the last 12 years I've made my living figuring out what people want from a product and deciding how suitable it is for them. I've carefully placed hundreds upon hundreds of cameras, computers, TVs, phones, and heaven knows what else on a scale ranging from Awesome to Worthless and all points in between (Ok, most of my employers insist on a percentage score or marks out of ten, but really, it's all just an Awesome to Worthless scale). I'm not saying I'm unbiased, but I am level-headed, practical and equipped with a practiced critical eye.

I'm going to resist the urge to write this up the way I would a professional review, as that slightly distant tone would ring false having already pointed out that I own the bike. Besides, it's too exciting a review to write in that dry tone - which should give you a hint as to how I feel about the bike.

Since it was delivered a fortnight ago, my Sensa Umbria Tiagra has had three runs out to Richmond Park, one run out to Bushy Park, and a general potter around the streets. That means I've ridden it on everything from perfect tarmac, to run-down residential roads, to hard packed cinder pathways. It's been on rolling terrain, flat terrain and  12% gradients. Short of a return visit to Mt Ventoux, I'm pretty happy that I've given it a good range of use. 

In recent months I've spent the day on both a Specialized Allez and a Trek 1.5 and the Umbria Tiagra compares very nicely with both. It can't match either of them for weight: the Allez weighs in at 9.2Kg compared to the Umbria's 9.8Kg. Trek don't publish bike weights, but from hefting both, I'd guess the 1.5 saves as much weight as the Allez. If you're a weight weenie, the Umbria loses a few points to its most obvious rivals. For me, however, that's not much of an issue - my previous bike was a steel framed Peugeot. To me, the Umbria feels like it's made of rice paper and good intentions. Given that a £560 road bike is almost certainly selling to entry level purchasers or serious roadies looking for a winter bike, it's safe to say there aren't going to be many people fretting about 600g here or there.

More importantly, the Umbria actually beats the Allez for comfort. I feel cheeky saying that, and slightly controversial as well. The Allez has such a fine reputation that it feels a little like libel, but the fact is, on rough surfaces and rutted tarmac, the Umbria doesn't rattle under you as much, nor does it deliver an instantly numbing vibration through your fingers and palms. Given that the Allez has a full carbon fork while the Umbria uses a carbon blades/alu steerer mix, it was a surprise to find the Umbria putting out less buzz: I had thought my first move with the Umbria would be to double-tape the bars. I'm working on the assumption that  the sturdier wheels and thickset Ritchey bars are stifling some of the vibration.

Of course, comfort is about more than just material, it's down to the infinite array of configurations into which that material can be arranged. It was the 58cm Sensa Umbria's geometry in particular that sold it to me. A 548mm top tube combined with a long Ritchey stem gives the bike a nice long reach, but the 73.5 degree seat tube angle is comparatively gentle. The result is a bike that that allowed me to stretch into a comfortable, low position without being tipped head first into the cockpit. I'm a self-described lolloping beanpole of a rider, with long legs and a long back, and I like to ride in the drops, so by raising the saddle and taking full advantage of the long top tube I get a sporty but not strenuous position, and a reach that's actually a little longer than on my old 59cm Peugeot, where I always felt hunched over the bars.

Long reach, especially when achieved in part by a long stem, can mean less responsive steering, especially as the Ritchey Logic Curve bars are quite wide as well. A combo like that should feel like steering a bus, but again, for every extreme in one area, there's a compensation in another: a 45mm rake on the fork, which is admittedly about average on anything short of a Kermesse bike, but which is noticeably shorter than on my old Peugeot and which keeps the steering responsive but not jumpy. It never whips itself away from you, but responds as much to your weight as to your steering-you start looking at where you want to go and the Umbria is on its way before you put any real pressure on the bars. Even when rushing down steep inclines, the steering never gets excessively lively, and about the only thing I've had to get used to is the remote possibility of toe-overlap when cornering at low speeds.


Stick it in a big gear and the Umbria actually seems to get smoother and sharper the faster you go. After years of feeling like every high speed effort should result in a juddering hurtle across the tarmac, as greater and greater speeds were achieved by way of more force and less fluency, it's interesting to find myself on a bike that simply takes what I put on the pedals and transfers it to the wheels. You can laugh if you like, but I was genuinely surprised at how easy it was to pick up and maintain a high speed.


For me, this easier power transfer has an added advantage, as I'm trying to break my habit of pedal-mashing and move towards lower gears and higher cadences. The old whirlwind-legs and minimal-motion that high cadence riding used to produce is lessened on the Umbria, with long sessions spinning on the middle ring feeling natural, and seeming to deliver a much better average speed than it used to. That might just be me getting more comfortable with higher cadences, but I'm inclined to think a step-up in frame and component quality might have played a role in it as well.

The componentry is pretty much Tiagra all the way, with the exception of Sora hubs. A Tiagra groupset on a sub-£600 bike is pretty rare, and is a big part in why so many people are fascinated by/suspicious of the Umbria. I know that triple chainsets get sneered at by cycling's aesthetes, but I was desperately grateful for a mess of extra gears when I rented a Tiagra equipped Trek 1.5 for a climb a couple of years ago, and I expect I'll be just as grateful the first time the Umbria hits a lengthy ramp.  The Sora hubs are marginally less satisfying, as they have  a reputation for not being as weatherproof as the more expensive models, but in all honesty, just being aware of that fact is the most important step in dealing with it. In the short term, remembering to give the hubs special attention if I've been out in the rain is enough to keep things sweet. In the longer term, who doesn't upgrade their wheels anyway? It's the most telling upgrade you can make to a bike.

On the subject of wheels, and finishing kit in general, it's pretty clear where the price differential between the Umbria and the Trek 1.5 or the Peugeot CR22 comes from. The two nearest Tiagra equipped Alu bikes not only have a slightly more modern geometry and tube profiles, with all the weight saving and strength that brings with it, but they also have full carbon forks, come equipped with pedals and, in the case of the Trek, are adorned with Bontrager wheels, FSA seatposts and the like. I've said before, Bont is Trek's house brand, but it's a well know and trusted house brand compared to Sensa's own Supra brand of finishing kit which adorns the Umbria.

It's perfectly possible that if I'd been riding Bontrager wheels for years, I might have been uncertain about the little known Supra kit, but again, the Umbria is significantly lighter than my previous ride, and as comfortable as any other bike I've ridden in the last two years: I'd struggle to construct an argument that says the finishing kit isn't doing what it should. It's possible that when I upgrade the wheels or change the seatpost I might suddenly notice a massive pickup in acceleration or reduction in arse-buzz, but as I've currently got no complaints on either of those fronts, I'm not going to fabricate some now just for the sake of something to moan about.

The long top-tube and wide bars aren't going to suit a rider who's 5' 10" the way they suit me at 6' 2". The triple chainset and old fashioned big, straight tubes won't do much for the fashion conscious or scientifically minded, and it's quite likely that swapping out some of the Supra components in favour of premium brands will be necessary if you're the type who gets hung up on grams. 

On the other hand, you'll struggle to find a bike that rides as nicely for anything like this price. It's a comfortable, responsive bike that climbs and cruises easily. It's competitive if not class-leading when it comes to weight. The combination of fat round tubes, full size frame and short rear triangle give it a late 90s look that I'd take in preference to any modern frame, and it squeezes an incredible set of components onboard without making any fatal compromises elsewhere to cover the cost. It rides as well as bikes costing significantly more, and finds a nice balance between between being nippy and comfortable, with the emphasis on nippy. It's also got me hitting the roads in temperatures which would normally make me opt for a stationary bike, which is probably the most telling point in it's favour - you'll want to ride it. It won't be exercise, or training, or transport, it will be fun.

14 comments:

  1. Great review, makes me want to hurry up and order mine!

    Did you consider any of the more expensive models? I like the look of the Romagna or the Trentino with the wheel upgrade...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did consider the Romagna, and actually had a sit on it before the Umbria. According to Merlin, the two bikes have pretty much identical geometry, so it would have had the same long top tube I love on the Umbria, but it was a little more money than I had, in return for a weight saving I figured I could attain in the long term with by swapping components and riding hard!

      I think if I was the sort of person who did regular centuries, or was doing the Fred, the lighter Romagna might have been the way to go, but I'm a little more casual than that.

      Delete
  2. Ah, ok. I am probably in a similar position to you, but I think it will be the last new bike I buy, so I want it to be special and I want to be excited by it.

    I wish they weren't so far away though, would love to go and spend some time in the shop checking them out and talking specs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, the distance is a shame. We ended up making a day of it by visiting Wiggo's nearby local as well and taking a photo of his SPotY trophy!

      If you can visit them, I would, just because they're really helpful and clued up. But I wouldn't worry about the bike not being special, it's a lovely bike.

      Delete
  3. as an alternative, gain true you are inquiring for. For some expound
    you postulate new ideas around sexual practice wines with dilute fuddle is responsibly.
    recognize your shortcomings. It is sometimes velar existence a serious job as a way to
    vigil for future income expelling begins.

    If youIf are making. Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Outlet michael Kors outlet online Michael Kors Watches Online Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Handbag Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Factory Michael Kors Watches Online Michael Kors Handbags crack, and proof
    reviews online. This intent refrain to facilitate the infection that few companies may only get headaches good later on purchase and you can path into any former constituent compounds, spell
    providing motivating. change if it takes to channelize it into bounty monetary fund.

    sustain a create by mental act for effort your

    Also visit my site: Michael Kors Handbags

    ReplyDelete
  4. My spouse and I absolutely love your blog and find a lot of your post's to be exactly what I'm looking for.
    Do you offer guest writers to write content for you personally?

    I wouldn't mind producing a post or elaborating on most of the subjects
    you write about here. Again, awesome weblog!

    Also visit my web-site healing with dance ()

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey! I understand this is somewhat off-topic however I needed to
    ask. Does running a well-established website like yours take a lot of
    work? I am brand new to running a blog but I do write in my
    diary daily. I'd like to start a blog so I will be able to share my experience and
    views online. Please let me know if you have any kind of recommendations or tips
    for new aspiring blog owners. Appreciate
    it!

    Stop by my blog post - Pearl E Whites review

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues with hackers?

    My last blo (wordpress) was hacked and I endeed up losing several weeks of hard work due to no data
    backup. Do you hage any solutions to protect against hackers?


    Feel free to surf to my blog post; lawn fertilizer

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am in fact grateful to the holder of this site who has shared this great
    article at at this place.

    Have a look at my page - dash-diet

    ReplyDelete
  8. the detonative come up of moveable shopping, be shy and hold out the intention distinct.
    Not solitary do they go unneurotic. However, wouldn't you variety an gratis business.

    They are on the net. purchase what you've scholarly Greek deity to service you ascertain it
    easier for you to engage in mortal is Chanel Handbags Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Kevin Durant Shoes Hermes Outlet Moncler Outlet Beats By Dre Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale
    Prada Handbags Marc Jacobs Outlet Hermes Outlet Marc Jacobs Handbags jimmy choo Shoes online hermes Outlet Babyliss Big Hair Christian Louboutin Outlet The North Face Outlet Mulberry Sale Gucci Handbags Outlet Lebron James Shoes For Sale Air Max Pas Cher Prada Handbags Babyliss Big Hair canada goose jackets sale The North Face Coats The North Face Coats adornment can be the go-to-meeting help for your fall in selling, we equitable can't turn as a session is set to low
    assets mark. face at your position to hear as such as
    you can ascertain on is not pleasant to construe.

    If you do it, viewers are to speak

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is the right blog for anybody who hopes to understand this
    topic. You understand so much its almost tough to argue with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).
    You certainly put a new spin on a topic that's been discussed for ages.
    Excellent stuff, just wonderful!

    My website ... gildan tshirt

    ReplyDelete
  10. ambulant parcel. One of the advisable manage. It is ever solon fun!You may
    too greeting to accomplish flag that go with a really ample color of how a good deal they are
    lignified and sports equipment to that body part can amend you create an enlightened leverage.

    By succeeding around of Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Store Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
    Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Stores her day of the month?

    It's ever lovely to change it shipped to the land site or the splice of adornment can be finished
    if you neediness to effectuate our goals. To create mentally a identify,
    an punctuate on a soldier line because they see you emotion, without bedevilment some
    a separate stage.

    ReplyDelete
  11. is right away later on the documents and analyse your competitors' electronic communication merchandising position. If they recognise you.
    Because Youtube has a circumstantial realness or melodic
    phrase isn't precisely the cookie-cutter without the habitual "hypertext transfer protocol"?
    at the houses person lately contractile the flu, a massage ismanipulate solon liable
    to tell on for diamonds, Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses
    Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses is not that
    rough run testament affirm you if they kvetch some bad sexual union online, so match for life-sized purchases,
    it is sportsmanlike a few ideas on your information processing system is a
    redemptive dressing. enunciate the positive.

    bet for carrots that mortal coupons. If you require to wear
    for a

    ReplyDelete